Inspection & maintenance9 min read

What a Roof Coating Assessment Checks Before Anything Goes On: Infrared Drone Scan, Cores, Adhesion Tests and Manufacturer Pre-Approval

Before a coating goes on, four things have to be proven: the roof is dry, the old surface will hold the new one, the damage is counted, and the manufacturer will warrant the result. Here is how A-1 proves each one, from an infrared drone scan at night to the manufacturer's sign-off, with the standards behind them and what we found on three real roofs.

ByA-1 Roofing

In short

A coating assessment has to prove four things before anything goes on: the roof is dry, the old surface will hold the new one, the damage is counted, and the manufacturer will stand behind the result. A-1 checks them in that order: an infrared drone scan at night, cores and a moisture meter to confirm it, wet and dry adhesion tests, then the manufacturer's own inspection.

Where this starts

This is the work after the restore-or-replace question has been answered. If you are still deciding whether your roof can be restored at all, our guide to the signs a roof needs replacing covers the wet insulation threshold and the conditions that rule restoration out. This post picks up once restoration is on the table and the question becomes whether this roof qualifies for this coating and this warranty.

Gaco, the manufacturer on all three jobs below, writes the checks into its application specifications, and they differ by roof. Its recoat specification, RC-S20-38-20, says 'a nuclear or infrared scan must be performed, and any wet roofing materials must be removed and replaced.' Its single-ply restoration specification, SP-S20-38-20 (revised May 2026), says a moisture survey 'is strongly recommended' and that all wet roofing materials must be removed and replaced. Both strongly recommend wet and dry adhesion tests before bidding, and both have the applicator give the owner a completed inspection report on the substrate.

Before you start: what to have ready

An assessment goes faster and finds more when the contractor walks in with the roof's history.

  • The original roof specification and warranty, if any survive, including the manufacturer and the system name.
  • Roof drawings or an aerial image with drains, curbs and roof levels marked.
  • A leak log: where, when, and after what kind of weather.
  • Who owns the rooftop equipment, because units on sleepers may have to be lifted later.
  • Access: a roof hatch or ladder, keys, and a contact who can be reached at night for the scan.

Step 1: Why start with an infrared drone scan at night?

Because wet insulation holds heat. ASTM C1153, the standard practice for locating wet insulation in roofing systems with infrared imaging, applies to imaging done at night on roofs with insulation above the deck in contact with the waterproofing, and it covers both ground-based and aerial inspections. After a sunny day the roof gives its heat back to the sky after dark. Dry insulation lets it go. Wet insulation holds it, and shows up warm on the thermal image.

A-1 flies its infrared scans by drone. A drone covers a large roof in one evening, sees every level of a stepped roof from above, and keeps a crew off an unlit roof. C1153 itself warns about the danger of walking roofs and of flying aircraft low at night.

Know what the scan cannot do. C1153 says the practice does not determine the cause of moisture or its point of entry. A warm patch on the image tells you where to cut a core.

Step 2: How do cores and a moisture meter confirm the scan?

They turn a reading into a measurement. A scan or a meter shows where moisture may be, and a core shows what is under the membrane. At The Monument in Rapid City, A-1 and a Holcim representative inspected and tested the Barnett Fieldhouse roofs together on August 23, 2023, before Phase 2 was priced. A moisture meter and core samples traced roughly 2,800 square feet of saturation to isolated ponding areas around unrepaired hail penetrations. The insulation underneath was intact, with some moisture present. That made it a repair, not a tear-off, and the wet insulation and underlayment were removed and replaced wherever the cores found them. On Colome Elementary's EPDM roof, A-1 found the wet areas by eye and confirmed them with cores.

Cores answer a second question too: how many roofs are already up there. Where a city or county has adopted the 2018 International Building Code, a re-cover is not permitted over a roof that is water-soaked or deteriorated, or over two or more existing layers, per NRCA's February 2019 summary. A protective roof coating does not count as a layer. That matters when the assessment rules out a coating and a re-cover is the fallback. A core shows the layers in cross section.

Step 3: What do the adhesion tests prove?

That the new coating will bond to the old surface, wet and dry. Gaco's recoat and single-ply specifications both call for a manufacturer-licensed applicator to run wet and dry adhesion tests by Gaco's own procedure, GI-1-3, using the exact products specified, and recommend running them before bidding.

The procedure is simple enough for an owner to watch. It calls for one test per 10,000 square feet, with a minimum of two, placed where the roof is most weathered. A 16-by-16-inch area is cleaned, an 8-by-12-inch patch is coated, and a 4-by-24-inch strip of polyester fabric is embedded with a 12-inch dry tail left free. After at least four days of cure, the tail is pulled at 90 degrees with a scale. A pass takes at least ten pounds of pull, and the coating has to tear within itself, leaving a layer on the roof with no bare spots. Wet tests go where the roof ponds: the cured patch sits under water or soaked rags for 24 hours before the pull.

A-1 runs pull tests on every warranted project and anywhere it has adhesion concerns. Kent Sybesma, A-1's Director of Operations: "Pull tests are always recommended. If there are any adhesion concerns a pull test is ordered."

At The Monument, several adhesion tests on the old PVC came back passing, which confirmed that once the field was cleaned and primed, the new silicone and the existing membrane would fuse into one system. Passing tests did not settle the surface question. On the job, two decades of weather had left the PVC so oxidized that a conventional wash was not leaving a surface the epoxy primer could grip, and A-1 added abrasive mechanical scrubbers ahead of the pressure washers.

Step 4: Why count the damage before pricing it?

Because a repair scope that is discovered during the job gets paid for twice: once in money and once in schedule. Check the slope while you are up there. Gaco's single-ply specification says the deck should have at least a quarter inch of rise per foot for drainage; its metal roof specification says 2:12 or greater. On the Barnett Fieldhouse, A-1 put the hail damage at about one hit per 250 square feet across the fields, previously patched with elastomeric products as a temporary measure. Counting it up front let the repair scope go into the price.

At Colome Elementary, the damage was delamination. The 20-year-old EPDM had pulled away from the deck at key stress points. Those areas were cut back and rebuilt with like EPDM materials before any coating went on, so the restoration went over sound substrate.

Step 5: What does the manufacturer's pre-approval involve?

On both warranted jobs below, the manufacturer looked at the roof itself before it agreed to warrant the result. At Colome, a Gaco representative inspected and approved the roof before any work began. Without that sign-off the district would not have qualified for the full factory warranty.

At The Monument, the paperwork went further. A-1 sent the pre-inspection report, the test results and the pre-installation notices to Holcim's technical department for review, and on October 13, 2023 Holcim issued a letter of intent to warrant the 20-year system. Gaco's adhesion test procedure, GI-1-3, puts part of that paperwork in writing: for warranted applications, the test results must be recorded and sent to Gaco with the Pre-Installation Notice. Its specifications add a pre-installation conference at the job site, where the manufacturer's representative, the applicator, the general contractor and the architect review methods, substrate conditions, scheduling and safety.

Step 6: What should the written report contain?

Everything above, on paper, before you sign. Gaco's spec requires the applicator to give the owner a completed inspection report verifying the substrate condition and any defects. A report worth having includes:

  • The infrared images, the conditions on the scan night, and a roof plan with the warm areas marked.
  • A core log: location, layers found, and wet or dry at each core.
  • Adhesion test results, wet and dry, with the products used.
  • The repair quantities: square feet of wet material to replace, damage counts, seams and flashings to rebuild.
  • The specification proposed and the warranty term and type it carries.
  • Photographs of every defect, keyed to the plan.

When is an infrared scan the wrong tool?

When the roof has no insulation above the deck for wet insulation to show up in. C1153 is written for roofs with insulation above the deck in contact with the waterproofing, so ask how yours is built before anyone books a night scan.

Metal roofs are assessed differently. Gaco's metal roof specification, MR-S20-38-20 (revised May 2026), has no moisture-scan step. Its examination asks for panels that are structurally sound and securely fastened, and warns that severe oxidation may make some panels unsuitable. A-1's March 30, 2026 inspection of the Was Ake' Building in Wagner graded a 1994 standing seam roof part by part: earlier seam repairs delaminating, loose and missing fasteners, rust spreading across the field, D+ overall with under two years of service life left. Every seam, bolt and penetration was sealed and the rust treated before the coating went on.

Where the assessment fails, and what to do when it does

Six ways an assessment goes wrong, each with the next move.

  • The weather on the scan night was wrong, and the image is flat or warm everywhere. C1153 sets the meteorological conditions an infrared survey needs. Do not price off a bad image. Rescan on a night that meets them, and lean on cores in the meantime.
  • The scan is clean but the roof still leaks. The scan finds wet insulation, not entry points. Inspect the details by hand: the curbs, flashings, drains and terminations, the places water gets in.
  • The cores show more wet material than the scan suggested. Trust the cores, re-map the wet area, and if it is large, go back to the restore-or-replace decision before anyone orders coating.
  • An adhesion test fails. Send the result to the manufacturer's technical services, change the preparation or primer as they direct, and retest. If it still fails, that surface comes off or the system changes.
  • The manufacturer will not pre-approve. Get the reasons in writing, fix what can be fixed, and resubmit. Do not proceed without the approval, because the warranty depends on it.
  • The contractor will not hand over the report. Make it a condition of the contract. The manufacturer's own spec says the owner gets one.

How do you know the assessment was done right?

A final inspection checks the installed coating, so it cannot prove the assessment found everything. What it does show is that the work was built on what the assessment found. At Colome, a Gaco-qualified inspector made a final inspection to confirm the roof met factory specification with no defects. At The Monument, Holcim's technical personnel inspected all the details and terminations, thickness cores were taken at random every 2,000 square feet, and the 20-year warranty was issued on labor and material, the same term Holcim had signaled in its letter of intent.

Keep the scan images, the core log and the adhesion results with the warranty. They are the baseline the next inspection, and the next recoat, starts from.

On The Monument's second phase, A-1 ran the cores, the adhesion tests and the hail count before it priced the work, which is how the moisture and hail damage were known before the bid. If a coating is on your list for next season, the scan and the cores are the part to book first.

What does this post not tell you?

This post describes A-1's assessment practice, Gaco's published recoat, single-ply and metal roof specifications (RC-S20-38-20, revised January 2024; SP-S20-38-20 and MR-S20-38-20, revised May 2026), its adhesion test procedure GI-1-3, and ASTM C1153-23 as summarized by ASTM. It is not a specification for your roof. Manufacturers set their own qualification and warranty requirements, and those govern. Neither this post nor A-1 Roofing guarantees that any roof will qualify for a coating or a warranty.

Questions owners ask next

Is a nuclear moisture survey better than infrared?
Neither is required over the other in Gaco's recoat specification, which accepts a nuclear or an infrared scan. A-1 uses an infrared drone scan because it covers the whole roof in one night. Whichever method is used, ask for cores to confirm the readings before the job is priced, as A-1 did on The Monument's Barnett Fieldhouse.
Does a recoat need the same assessment as a first restoration?
In Gaco's specifications the recoat is the stricter of the two on moisture. The recoat specification, RC-S20-38-20, says a nuclear or infrared scan 'must be performed'; the single-ply restoration specification, SP-S20-38-20, says a moisture survey 'is strongly recommended.' Both require wet material to be removed and replaced, both strongly recommend wet and dry adhesion tests before bidding, and both call for a pre-installation conference. Our roof recoating process guide walks through the full recoat sequence.
Can the drone scan be done in daylight to save a night visit?
Not under ASTM C1153, which is written for infrared imaging at night, when the roof is giving back the day's heat and wet areas stand out. A daylight flight is useful for photographs and a visual survey of the roof. The moisture survey still happens after dark.

Related on this site

Sources

  1. ASTM C1153-23 — Standard Practice for Location of Wet Insulation in Roofing Systems Using Infrared Imaging, ASTM's scope summary (active, Oct 2023): night imaging, ground-based and aerial; §4.3 does not determine cause or point of entry
  2. Gaco — RC-S20-38-20, GacoFlex S20 Series for Re-Coat, application specification (revised January 2024): nuclear or infrared scan must be performed, adhesion tests, inspection report, pre-installation conference
  3. Gaco — SP-S20-38-20, GacoFlex S20 Series over Single-Ply, application specification (revised May 2026): moisture survey strongly recommended, 0.25 in per ft slope
  4. Gaco — MR-S20-38-20, GacoFlex S20 Series over Metal Roof, application specification (revised May 2026): panels structurally sound and securely fastened, 2:12 slope
  5. Gaco — GI-1-3, Adhesion Testing Procedure for GacoFlex Coating Systems (revised June 2020)
  6. NRCA Professional Roofing — Reroofing by the book (Feb 1, 2019): IBC 2018 re-cover limits
  7. A-1 case study — The Monument, Rapid City SD
  8. A-1 case study — Colome Elementary School, Colome SD
  9. A-1 case study — Was Ake' Building, Wagner SD