Our take, up front
Silicone goes on top. On a coated foam roof in South Dakota, Nebraska, Iowa, Minnesota or Wyoming, the topcoat has to survive ponding water, ultraviolet light and a repair crew after every storm, and silicone does all three. Where hail is a real threat, our standard answer is an extra coat of silicone, which we offer on hail-prone jobs. In our experience polyurea beats silicone on hail and silicone beats polyurea on UV. We only recommend polyurea as a basecoat the manufacturer lists and warrants under the silicone.
Polyurea wins the strength numbers by a wide margin, and that is the strongest argument against our pick. We sprayed it for years, and we take it seriously below.
What are we actually comparing?
Two coatings that go over spray foam for different reasons. Silicone is the weathering surface: Gaco's GacoFlex S20, the silicone on four of A-1's five published case studies, is a single-component 100 percent silicone sprayed at 38 dry mils for a 20-year warranty. Polyurea is a two-component coating that sets in seconds. General Coatings, which sells both pure and hybrid polyureas, markets its Ultra-Tuff line as a durable hail-resistance basecoat for spray foam roofs and says a topcoat is required for UV reflectance.
That last line frames the whole comparison. General Coatings sells its roof polyurea as a basecoat, so on a coated foam roof today the practical choice is silicone alone or polyurea under silicone. We used to leave polyurea exposed, and we explain below why we stopped.
Paired comparison: polyurea vs. silicone across eight criteria
Figures are each manufacturer's published values. Polyurea: General Coatings Ultra-Tuff 2800, a fast-set aromatic basecoat for spray foam roofing, and Ultra-Tuff 2900, a pure aromatic polyurea, both data sheets dated 2020. Silicone: Gaco GacoFlex S20, data sheet revised August 2026. Lab values from different makers are not a head-to-head test, so read them as orders of magnitude.
- Tensile strength. Polyurea: 2,600 psi, plus or minus 200 (Ultra-Tuff 2800); 3,500 psi (Ultra-Tuff 2900). Silicone: 450 psi at 73 degrees and 574 psi at 0 degrees (S20). Verdict: polyurea, by roughly six times.
- Elongation at break. Polyurea: 400 percent, plus or minus 50, at 75 degrees (2800); 200 to 350 percent (2900). Silicone: 174 percent at 73 degrees and 169 percent at 0 degrees. Verdict: polyurea.
- Tear resistance. Polyurea: more than 450 pounds per inch (2900, ASTM D624); the 2800 sheet lists 420. Silicone: 38.5 pounds per inch (S20, ASTM D624). On the same test method, polyurea tears about twelve times harder. Verdict: polyurea.
- Sunlight and reflectivity. Polyurea: General Coatings says Ultra-Tuff 2800 will tend to yellow, darken and go flat in UV light, and should be topcoated within six hours with an aliphatic polyurethane, silicone or acrylic for fire classification. Silicone: Gaco lists S20 at 0.88 solar reflectance new and 0.63 after accelerated aging. Verdict: silicone.
- Standing water. Silicone: Gaco's S20 data sheet reports 450 psi and 125 percent elongation after 8,670 hours immersed in 150-degree water, and A-1 chose S20 at Woonsocket because silicone is unaffected by ponding. We also re-sloped that roof with new foam so it would drain, because ponding had destroyed the original system. Polyurea: neither General Coatings sheet addresses ponding. Verdict: silicone.
- Application. Polyurea: a plural-component, heated, high-pressure rig at about 2,500 psi, a pot life of 4 to 8 seconds, trained or manufacturer-approved applicators only, and overspray warning signs at least 100 feet out. Silicone: sprayed from airless rigs; at The Monument A-1 ran 5,000 psi at the tip. Verdict: silicone, because more crews can install and repair it.
- Repair and recoat. Silicone: Gaco publishes a full recoat specification, and after hail at Woonsocket each cut was repaired individually and the field recoated in six days with an ordinary airless rig. Polyurea: repairable too. Our own 50,000 square foot polyurea roof was caulked, washed and recoated after each of two hailstorms, and we have recoated several old polyurea roofs with silicone. But a polyurea recoat means bringing the plural-component rig back, and the 0-to-6-hour recoat window on the Ultra-Tuff sheets applies only between coats during the original spray. Verdict: silicone, narrowly, because more crews can do the repair.
- Installed cost. Commercial Roof Guide (updated March 2026) puts silicone at $2.50 to $4.50 per square foot and polyurethane coatings at $3.00 to $5.00, noting the polyurethanes are often used as a basecoat under a silicone or acrylic topcoat. The guide prices silicone at 20 to 30 mils, thinner than the 38 to 40 mils on our jobs. The only polyurea figures we found come from a polyurea manufacturer, ArmorThane, and its own pages disagree: $3.00 to $6.00 per square foot installed in its roof coating guide (updated March 2026), and $8.00 to $15.00 on its flat-roof waterproofing page. A polyurea basecoat under silicone pays for both layers. Verdict: silicone, on the comparable numbers available.
What does the strength gap mean when hail hits?
Less than the numbers suggest, but not nothing. UPC Foam's guide to hail and spray foam roofing describes the usual system as at least an inch, more often two to three, of high-density foam under 25 to 30 mils of acrylic, silicone or polyurethane coating, and says it can usually take half-inch to one-inch hail with only a small dent and no coating cracks. The Roofing Industry Committee on Weather Issues 2004 investigation of the Oklahoma City storms (a legacy benchmark), which the guide quotes, inspected five foam roofs: the three hit by hail from just over one inch to two inches had coating fractures, and the two hit by half-inch to one-inch stones did not.
The same guide lists five ways to raise hail resistance. It recommends foam over 3.0 pounds per cubic foot with 60 psi compressive strength, a third coat of coating because added thickness significantly increases tensile strength, a coating that combines tensile strength with flexibility, and granules or crushed aggregate, which field studies show reduce hail damage more than coating alone.
That is why our first move in hail country is thickness: on hail-prone jobs, and on foam roofs above all, we offer an extra coat. We are also plain with owners that foam roofs take hail damage, and we urge them to carry insurance that covers a hail claim. Granules are the other option. Gaco's recoat specification includes an optional granular coat: a light silicone pass with white roofing granules broadcast at 30 pounds per 100 square feet.
The FM hail classes, the test energies and the listings that sit behind them are in our post on what hail does to a spray foam roof. The short version for this comparison: a hail rating belongs to a listed assembly, not to a chemistry.
How do the two hold up through an Upper Midwest winter?
Both stay flexible in the cold on paper, and the cold is the test that matters here. Gaco's S20 data sheet reports 574 psi of tensile strength and 169 percent elongation at 0 degrees, against 450 psi and 174 percent at 73, so the silicone gets slightly stronger and barely stiffer as it freezes. General Coatings lists both Ultra-Tuff sheets as passing ASTM D2136 low-temperature flexibility. The 2800 sheet gives two dry service ranges, minus 40 to 250 degrees in one table and minus 10 to 200 in another, and both sheets list 40 to 120 degrees wet.
The cycling is what our roofs live with. Counting days when the high was above freezing and the low below it in NOAA's daily airport records for 1991 to 2020, Scottsbluff averages 140 a year, Cheyenne 129, Rapid City 124, Sioux Falls 90 and Minneapolis 68. Hail arrives on top of that. In a legacy benchmark from August 28, 2024, the Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis reported, citing National Weather Service records, that South Dakota's hail season grew from an average of 138 days in the 1970s to 173 days in the 2014 to 2023 period. On August 11, 2026, the National Weather Service in Rapid City logged 4.00-inch hail northwest of Oglala.
A coating in this climate takes a freeze, a thaw and a hailstone in the same season, and sometimes the same week. That is the argument for the coating you can repair quickly after the storm, not only the one with the highest tensile number before it.
What should you ask before choosing either?
Eight questions to ask before the bid is signed.
- Which exact products, and which data sheet revisions? Ask for the sheets and check the test temperatures, because 73 degrees and 0 degrees give different numbers.
- Which system specification, and what warranty term does it carry? The topcoat, its dry film thickness and any basecoat should all be named in the manufacturer's written specification.
- Is a granular coat included, and is it in the specification?
- What is the recoat specification for this system ten or twenty years from now, and who can perform it?
- If a polyurea layer is proposed, how many polyurea roofs has this crew sprayed, and on what equipment?
- If the building is FM-insured, which RoofNav listing does the proposed assembly match?
- If the roof is silicone today, what will the next recoat be, and does that product's data sheet list existing silicone as a substrate?
- Does the coating warranty cover hail? General Coatings' data-sheet warranty excludes damage from acts of nature, so check the system warranty and your insurance.
What has hail done to the roofs we installed?
Four of the five jobs in A-1's published case studies carry a silicone top: Gaco S20 at 38 mils over foam at Woonsocket, S20 at about 40 mils over EPDM at Colome Elementary, S-2000 at 38 mils across The Monument's 193,018 square feet of PVC, and S20 over metal at the Was Ake' Building. The fifth, Freeman Shopping Center, is spray foam with an acrylic topcoat.
Polyurea is not new to us. In the early-to-mid 2000s we sprayed a lot of it and sold it as the premium system, the one that was supposed to be bulletproof. Several of those roofs took hail, and in our experience the polyurea held up to it far better than any acrylic or silicone would have. Our largest, at 50,000 square feet, covers an industrial building in rural Brule County, SD, with mechanic, woodworking, welding and ag machinery shops, a truck washout bay and a parking garage. It is VFI-540, an aromatic aluminum polyurea. It came through two storms with tennis-ball-size hail, which Kent Sybesma, A-1's Director of Operations, puts at about 2018 and 2021. It performed remarkably well, and it still needed a simple caulk, wash and recoat both times.
We stopped spraying it for three reasons: the material cost, the complex application, and the lack of UV stability in the polyurea we used. Aromatic polyureas, like both General Coatings sheets in this post, yellow and break down in sunlight. Aliphatic polyureas are sold as the UV-stable grade, at a higher price. A couple of those roofs got an acrylic topcoat so the owner could have a color other than the standard aluminum grey. The ones left uncoated broke down in the sun and often needed a recoat at around 8 years old. We have since recoated several with silicone, for that UV damage and for damage from very large hail.
Silicone is harder to apply than acrylic. We use it on top because it is UV stable, lasts longer, carries longer warranty terms and is unaffected by the ponding that flat and low-slope roofs see. It still needs a roof that drains: Gaco's recoat specification calls for at least a quarter inch of slope per foot.
In 2024 a hailstorm cut open the S20 membrane on the Woonsocket School District roof, two years after A-1 restored it. Each impact cut was repaired individually with reinforced flashing-grade silicone, the roof was washed, and a fresh S20 topcoat went over the field under Gaco's recoat specification. Six working days, no disruption to the school, and the 20-year warranty was reinstated.
Neither roof stopped the hail. Both turned it into a repair. The silicone repair needed only an airless rig and the manufacturer's recoat specification.
When does a polyurea basecoat earn its place?
When hail is the dominant risk, the roof drains well, and the manufacturer lists the combination. General Coatings sells its Ultra-Tuff 2800 basecoat for exactly that use and says it should be topcoated within six hours for fire classification. The 2026 Commercial Roof Guide figures describe polyurethane basecoats under silicone or acrylic as a common pairing, and as the coating with the best impact and abrasion resistance, which also makes them a fit for walkways and equipment areas that see constant foot traffic.
The conditions matter more than the chemistry. A polyurea layer is only as good as the foam under it and the topcoat over it, and the warranty only covers the assembly the manufacturer wrote. Ask for the system specification and the warranty language before anyone sprays a basecoat.
A-1 does not typically install a polyurea basecoat, though we will when the specification calls for one. On top, our choice turns on drainage: acrylic on a roof that drains well, silicone on one that ponds. And once a roof is silicone, it can only be restored with silicone.
Where does this advice fail?
Four places, and each one changes the answer.
- An FM-insured building with a hail requirement. The rating is whatever the listed assembly in RoofNav says. If the listed assembly your carrier wants uses a polyurea or urethane layer, that settles it, whatever this post says.
- A roof with no ponding and constant foot traffic. Polyurea's tear and abrasion numbers matter more there, and a polyurethane or polyurea walkway layer under the topcoat is a reasonable design.
- A crew without plural-component equipment. General Coatings limits Ultra-Tuff to trained or manufacturer-approved applicators, and a heated 2,500 psi rig with a four-to-eight-second pot life leaves little room for a crew that rarely runs one. Ask how many polyurea roofs the crew has done.
- Our own evidence. A-1's polyurea roofs date from the early-to-mid 2000s, and the data sheets in this post are newer than those jobs. Today's polyureas may behave differently from the ones we sprayed. Weigh that accordingly.
What does this post not tell you?
This post compares manufacturers' published data sheet values and an independent cost guide's estimates as of October 2026. Lab values from different manufacturers are not a head-to-head test, and the polyurea data sheets cited are dated 2020. It is not a specification or engineering advice. Hail ratings belong to specific listed assemblies, warranties belong to specific manufacturer systems, and neither this post nor A-1 Roofing guarantees how any coating will perform in a given storm.
Questions owners ask next
- Is polyurea the same thing as a polyurethane coating?
- No, though the lines blur. General Coatings sells a pure polyurea (Ultra-Tuff 2200 and 2900) and hybrids that blend polyurea and polyurethane chemistry (Ultra-Tuff 2400 and 2800). Ask which one is on the bid, because the data sheets differ.
- Can silicone go over an existing polyurea or urethane roof coating?
- Usually, with preparation. We have recoated several of our old polyurea roofs with silicone. Gaco's recoat specification says most existing elastomeric coating systems can be recoated with proper surface preparation, including primer, once the existing coating type is identified, and it recommends wet and dry adhesion tests before bidding. Going the other way, over a roof that is already silicone, check that the new product's data sheet lists existing silicone as a substrate. Gaco's S20 sheet does, and says existing silicone should not be primed.
- Do granules change how the roof is maintained?
- They are part of Gaco's own recoat specification as an optional coat, so they are part of the manufacturer's system. Ask the contractor to show the granular coat in the written specification, so it is covered by the same warranty as the rest of the roof.
- Does a polyurea basecoat do anything besides resist impact?
- It can act as a vapor retarder. General Coatings rates Ultra-Tuff 2800 as a Class II vapor retarder at 35 to 50 dry mils and a Class I retarder at 80 dry mils or more, which matters on cold storage and other buildings with strong vapor drive. Gaco, by contrast, does not recommend its S20 recoat system on cold storage or cryogenic structures.
Related on this site
- Silicone and acrylic roof coatings
- Spray polyurethane foam roofing
- Commercial roof restoration
- Commercial roof inspection
- The roof recoating process, step by step
- Spray polyurethane foam vs. TPO
- Commercial roofing cost guide
- Case study: Woonsocket School District
- Nebraska commercial roofing
- South Dakota commercial roofing
- What hail does to a spray foam roof
Sources
- General Coatings — Polyurea coatings: Ultra-Tuff as a hail-resistance basecoat for spray foam roofs; topcoat required for UV reflectance
- General Coatings — Ultra-Tuff 2800 Fast-Set Polyurea Base Coating, technical data sheet (2020): 2,600 psi, 400% elongation, 420 pli tear; yellows in UV; topcoat within six hours
- General Coatings — Ultra-Tuff 2900 High Performance Polyurea, technical data sheet (2020): 3,500 psi; 200–350% elongation; recoat 0–6 hours; 30-day cure; wet and dry service ranges
- Gaco — GacoFlex S20 Series Product Data Sheet (revised August 2026): 450 psi and 174% at 73°F; 574 psi and 169% at 0°F; tear 38.5 lb/in
- ArmorThane (polyurea manufacturer) — Roof coating guide, updated March 2026: polyurea $3.00–$6.00 per sq ft installed
- ArmorThane (polyurea manufacturer) — Flat roof waterproofing: polyurea $8–$15 per sq ft
- Gaco — RC-S20-38-20 recoat specification (revised June 2021): reflectance 0.88; optional granular coat; recoating existing coatings
- UPC Foam — Hail and SPF Roofing, quoting RICOWI's 2004 Oklahoma City investigation (thickness, granules, coating selection)
- Commercial Roof Guide — Commercial Roof Cost Guide (2026), updated March 2026: silicone $2.50–$4.50, polyurethane $3.00–$5.00 per sq ft (industry estimates)
- Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis — Homeowners insurance costs are growing fast (Aug 28, 2024): South Dakota hail season 138 to 173 days
- NWS Rapid City — August 11, 2026 severe thunderstorm event summary (4.00-inch hail near Oglala)
- NOAA NCEI — Global Historical Climatology Network daily records (freeze-thaw days computed for 1991 to 2020)
- A-1 case study — Woonsocket School District, Woonsocket SD
- A-1 case study — The Monument, Rapid City SD
